Welcome to Papa’s Tomato Pies
Papa’s Tomato Pies, located in Robbinsville, NJ, is a gem in the pizza scene, blending tradition with innovation. Established with a passion for crafting the perfect tomato pie, they offer a delightful array of specialty pizzas, such as the Mustard Pie and Italian Stallion, each bursting with flavor. Known for their casual atmosphere and friendly service, this eatery caters to families, groups, and pizza lovers alike. With options for takeout, delivery, and outdoor seating, it's an inviting spot for lunch or dinner. Dining here feels like a celebration of Italian cuisine, making every bite a nostalgic experience.
Papa’s Tomato Pies: Reviews & Ratings
Was craving my last Jersey pizza before leaving town and wow this was delicious! The crust was thin and light and just the perfect amount of crispy. The tomatoes tasted so yummy and perfectly sweet. Couldnt have asked for a more perfect ...
Surely a legendary spot, Papas has been operating since 1912. The tomato pie remains the best Ive had ever especially the remarkable sauce. I recall being at the previous location in Trenton and seeing 2 fellows hovering over a fresh ...
Authentic Trenton Tomato Pie crispy crust, deep red tomato sauce and great blend of flavors. We added fresh garlic and sausage. The sausage was delicious and nice that it was chunks instead of sliced. Perfectly cooked ...
Pizza was outstanding! We got the mustard and tomato pie and it was the best pizza Ive ever had!! Wow.... Place is a little dated but I think they do it on purpose to give the old pizza ...
Old fashioned place, old fashioned tomato pies, excellent waitress, great vibe!! Established in 1912! We love these places that have been around forever Thin crust, lots of tomatoes. Our pizza had sausage and hot peppers. The three ...
A New Jersey institution! Classic pizza restaurant serving delicious tomato pie! We ordered a plain and a sausage and garlic. Both were excellent as evidenced with the fact I ate four slices! With a crisp thin crust, is unique creation ...
One of my best pizza experiences in New Jersey. Went with the regular enjoyed every single bite. Crunchy thin with delicious sauce cheese combo. I cant wait to come back.
Dropped in and had a large mustard pie with pepperoni and mushrooms. It was delicious, even my mom loved it and she is not a pizza fan. Mustard pie is the way to go!
Location
-
19 Robbinsville-Allentown Rd Robbinsville, NJ 08691 United States Hotline: (609) 208-0006
Welcome to the delightful world of Papa’s Tomato Pies, an Italian pizzeria nestled in the heart of Robbinsville, New Jersey. Known for its casual ambiance and a menu that strikes the perfect balance between tradition and originality, Papa’s Tomato Pies is a must-visit for both local residents and pizza aficionados alike.
At Papa's, the star of the show is undeniably the Tomato Pie. For just $15, you can experience a delightful blend of flavors that pay homage to authentic Italian pizza. But it doesn't stop there; the menu features an array of specialty pies sure to captivate your palate. The Mustard Pie, a local favorite, uniquely places spicy brown mustard beneath a layer of cheese, resulting in a flavor explosion that you won’t soon forget ($17). For those craving something hearty, the Italian Stallion pie combines white pizza with sausage, broccoli rabe, and garlic, striking the perfect meaty note for pizza lovers at just $21.
- Tomato Pie - $15
- Mustard Pie - $17
- The Italian Stallion - $21
- The Veggie Pie - $22
- The Italian Flag - $22
For those seeking a lighter touch, the selection of soups and salads is delightful. The Pasta e Fagiole and Chicken Pastina soups, both priced at $4, are perfect starters. A crisp Caprese Salad, complete with fresh mozzarella and basil pesto, is a refreshing complement to your meal for just $7.
If sandwiches are more your style, Papa’s offers a range of options like the classic Cheese Steak and hearty Meatball Parmesan, all reasonably priced at $9. Each sandwich comes with robust flavors that further highlight the quality and care in each dish.
Beyond the delicious offerings, Papa’s Tomato Pies provides a variety of conveniences, such as delivery, takeout, catering, and even outdoor seating for those wanting to enjoy their meal al fresco. Families are welcome, with options suitable for kids, and the venue is dog-friendly, making it an ideal spot for gatherings.
With its delicious food, welcoming atmosphere, and community spirit, Papa’s Tomato Pies promises not just a meal but a delightful dining experience. Whether you're stopping by for a casual lunch or a festive dinner with friends and family, prepare to be charmed by the flavors and hospitality at this Robbinsville gem.
For those looking to visit, find them at 19 Robbinsville-Allentown Rd, Robbinsville, NJ 08691, or call at (609) 208-0006 for reservations and inquiries. Don't miss out on Happy Hour specials and a cozy dining experience where every bite makes you feel right at home.
